Blog Layout

Sell or Rent: Deciding What to do With Your Home

Jan 10, 2024

The decision on whether to sell or rent your home is trickier than other financial decisions because of the emotional ties. To make the best decision possible, evaluate the income, growth, and tax advantages of selling vs. renting and how it would advance your long-term goals.

If you are relocating due to a job change or retirement, consider keeping your present home and renting it out rather than selling it and transferring the equity to a new home or reinvesting the proceeds.


The first question to ask yourself is: "Why am I considering this strategy?" Here are some of the more common reasons:

  1. Your home has appreciated considerably, and you don't want to sell while prices are still on an uptrend.
  2. You would enjoy receiving rental income as a supplement to other retirement income.
  3. You are still determining if the relocation is permanent and if you want to keep the home if you decide to return.
  4. You want to keep the house in the family for children or grandchildren.


Understanding your long-term objectives will provide direction in analyzing the sell-versus-rent question.


Appreciation

If your main objective is further price appreciation, when will you know the right time to sell? In other words, what is your exit strategy? If you see the home as a growth investment, is this the best investment right now, considering your objectives and the rest of your portfolio? If you had a lump sum of cash equal to the equity in the home, would you buy this home and rent it out or invest in something else?


This line of questioning determines if you have an unhealthy attachment to the home as an investment—not uncommon when a particular asset has "been good" to you. If emotions cloud your judgment, try viewing this asset within the context of other possible investments and ask yourself how much more you think the house might appreciate. If it's already worth far more than you ever imagined, you might deem the house overvalued and reconsider the wisdom of keeping it.


Or it could be that your home hasn't appreciated very much. If you have a loss on the house, you may be better off converting it to a rental before selling since a loss on a personal residence is not tax deductible. Maintaining it as a rental may give the home time to appreciate. If it doesn't, you could sell it after renting it for a while and claim the loss on your tax return. (Be aware, however, that the IRS has disallowed loss deductions for rentals preceding a sale because there was no "profit motive" for the rental.) The property's basis would be the lesser of the adjusted cost basis or fair market value at the time of conversion, and they would need documentation to claim the loss on their expense, as they were the ones on the hook for the damages.

Income

Rental income can be a good source of retirement income—as long as the numbers work. One advantage of rental income is that it generally rises with inflation. However, the ability to raise rents varies with supply and demand in the local area, which may change during the ownership period.


Suppose you are keeping the house for income. In that case, you will need to do a market analysis to determine the appropriate amount of rent to charge. You will also need to fully understand ownership costs (maintenance, repairs, insurance, and so forth) to determine your net cash flow. Consultation with real estate agents and CPAs may be necessary.


Numerous online calculators can help you decide if your home is the best source of income or if you could do better with another investment. Most calculators will ask you for the expected monthly rent, ownership costs (taxes, capital improvements, and monthly maintenance costs), and the likely sale price of the home to calculate the "capitalization rate," which you can then compare with the rate on long-term Treasuries.


If the cap rate is higher than the current rate on Treasuries, keeping the home as a rental is a good deal; if not, it's not. Ensure you are not forcing the numbers to work by assuming too-high rent or too-low expenses. Accurate assumptions are crucial to understanding the investment merits of the deal. Ultimately, the sell-versus-rent decision will hinge on the ratio of rents to prices in your neighborhood. Low rents and high home prices do not bode if you're considering leveraging your equity for an ongoing income stream.


In addition to the ratio of rents to prices, you need to understand the tax rules pertaining to income property. Rental income is taxable; however, the following expenses are deductible from rental income on Schedule E of Form 1040:

  • Real estate taxes
  • Management expenses
  • Maintenance expenses
  • Traveling expenses to look after the property
  • Legal expenses
  • Mortgage interest
  • Insurance premiums
  • Depreciation of the building (not the land) based on a 27½-year recovery period
  • Depreciation of furniture, carpeting, and appliances based on a five-year recovery period


These tax breaks make the deal more attractive than you had anticipated. On the other hand, the above list may make you aware of expenses you have yet to consider when calculating net cash flow. If you are investing for income, you need to be realistic about how much that net income will be.


Temporary Rental

If you are still determining if the relocation will be permanent and you want the option of moving back into the home, renting it out for some time may be a good solution. However, you should keep an eye on the calendar and, if you sell, do it within three years to qualify for the $250,000 / $500,000 capital gains tax exclusion. According to the rules, even if a home has been converted to a rental, sellers can qualify for the capital gains tax exclusion if they've lived in the home as a principal residence for two out of the five years preceding the sale. Be sure you allow enough time to get the house on the market, sold, and closed before the three-year window closes.


Leaving It to Heirs

As more young people get priced out of the housing market, you may want to keep your home for your children and grandchildren, renting it to the kids or unrelated tenants; this is also an excellent tax-planning strategy because your heirs will receive a step-up in basis when they inherit the property. Remember, if you rent the house to family members at below-market rates, you may only deduct expenses to the extent of the actual rent received (i.e., you can't claim excess losses).


Analyzing the investment merits of a principal residence converted to a rental property is slightly trickier than any other investment because of your emotional connection to the property. You've enjoyed living in the home, made money on the home, and now want to keep the home as an investment. But as with any investment, you must evaluate the house based on its economic merits in light of your personal objectives and considering the property's prospects for income, growth, and/or tax advantages.

Work With Clayton Financial Group

At Clayton Financial Group, we help our clients achieve their plans for life and take their growth and security seriously. We are an independent boutique advisory firm with national coverage and decades of industry experience. If you're looking for help with investment planning, tax planning, risk management, estate planning, and more, look no further: let's connect today.

12 Apr, 2024
If your employer health plan is a health savings account (HSA) paired with a high-deductible health plan (HDHP), you may have a problem when you turn 65.
08 Mar, 2024
Qualified Charitable Distributions From an IRA Provide Individuals Over 70½ With a Way To Receive Income Tax Savings on Charitable Gifts—Even if They Decide To Take the Newly Increased Standard Deduction.
13 Feb, 2024
Get a jump-start on creating an organization system for your financial paperwork.
13 Dec, 2023
With these year-end giving strategies, you can make charitable donations in ways that are most beneficial to your financial situation.
20 Nov, 2023
IRA or 401(k)? Know the key differences between these two popular retirement plans to ensure you are saving in the right account.
13 Oct, 2023
Nobody looks forward to discussing finances and elder care with their parents, but every family needs to do it. These tips will help you start the conversation now and get a plan in place before you urgently need it.
By Lynn O'Shaughnessy 13 Sep, 2023
If You’ve Started College Planning, You’ve Heard About the FAFSA.
11 Aug, 2023
There are many misconceptions when it comes to estate planning. People miss out on the chance to preserve wealth in their family because they think they are too young to start planning an estate or need more assets. The reality is that any of us can pass unexpectedly, and having a plan helps our loved ones honor our legacy and navigate through the period after our death with more direction. Let's discuss the difference between an estate and a will, when to start planning, and items to consider. Estate vs. Will: Understanding the Differences Estate plans and Wills seem interchangeable, but they serve different purposes. A Will outlines your wishes for distributing your assets after your passing, while an estate plan encompasses a broader spectrum of considerations. An estate plan can include a Will, but also covers aspects like healthcare directives, guardianship for minor children, and strategies for minimizing taxes. When to Start Estate Planning Many individuals wonder when the right time is to start estate planning. The answer is simple: as early as possible. Life is unpredictable, and waiting for significant life events to trigger estate planning can lead to complications. If you're getting married, becoming a parent, acquiring substantial assets, or starting a business, it's time to create an estate plan. Don't delay; the peace of mind that comes with knowing your affairs are in order is invaluable. How Often to Update Your Estate Plan Creating an estate plan is not a one-time endeavor; it's an ongoing process. Changes in your life circumstances, financial situation, and even laws and regulations can affect the effectiveness of your plan. Reviewing and updating your estate plan every 3-5 years or after significant life events is recommended. Keeping your plan current ensures that it accurately reflects your wishes and the current legal landscape. Accounts and Financial Assets Your estate plan should encompass all your financial assets, including traditional accounts and digital holdings. Documenting your account information and login credentials is essential for your beneficiaries to access these assets. Failing to account for digital assets can lead to valuable resources being lost or inaccessible. Property and Heirlooms The sentimental value attached to specific properties and heirlooms can complicate estate planning. Strategies like gifting, trusts, and detailed instructions ensure these items are passed down smoothly without causing family disputes. Balancing financial implications with emotional connections is vital to preserving your legacy and your family's harmony. Business Succession Planning Business owners have unique considerations when it comes to estate planning. Without a proper business succession plan, the future of your enterprise could be uncertain. Addressing questions of who will take over, how ownership will transition, and how the business's stability will be maintained is crucial. A well-thought-out business succession plan protects not only your legacy but also the livelihoods of your employees.
14 Jul, 2023
What is a 529 Plan? A 529 Plan is a tax-advantaged savings plan that encourages individuals to save for qualified education expenses. Administered by states or educational institutions, it provides a structured approach to funding education, whether it's for your children, grandchildren, or even yourself. This investment vehicle offers attractive benefits, making it an appealing choice for many families. Tax Benefits One of the key advantages of a 529 Plan is the array of tax benefits it offers. First and foremost, your contributions grow tax-free over time, allowing your savings to compound and potentially grow significantly. Additionally, withdrawals made for qualified education expenses are tax-free, making it a highly tax-efficient way to fund education. Some states offer additional tax benefits, such as deductions or credits for contributions to a 529 Plan. These tax advantages can maximize your savings and boost your educational funding strategy. Financial Aid Considerations When planning for education, financial aid is a critical aspect to consider. Many families worry that having a 529 Plan might negatively impact their eligibility for financial aid. However, the impact is relatively low compared to other types of accounts. The assets in a 529 Plan are generally treated as parental assets, with a lower impact on financial aid calculations. So, by saving in a 529 Plan, you can secure your educational funding while minimizing potential disruptions to your financial aid prospects. Transferability and Control A 529 Plan offers exceptional flexibility in transferring funds between beneficiaries within the same family. Suppose one beneficiary decides not to pursue higher education or there are remaining funds after one beneficiary completes their education. In that case, you can easily transfer the funds to another eligible family member without tax consequences. This transferability ensures that your savings are utilized effectively and that you retain control over the funds until they are needed. Additionally, the SECURE Act 2.0 made it possible for $35,000 to be transferred to a Roth IRA if a 529 beneficiary does not need their funds for education. However, the 529 Plan must have been in existence for at least 15 years prior to the rollover for this option. Further, any 529 contributions made within the last five years before the rollover are not eligible. If the 529 Plan meets this requirement, then contributions can be made annually to the beneficiary's Roth IRA up to the Roth's maximum amount each year. The contributions are limited to the annual Roth ceiling, and up to a lifetime max of $35k (i.e. the full $35k can not be transferred into the account at one time). Qualified Education Expenses To take full advantage of a 529 Plan, it's essential to understand what expenses qualify. Qualified education expenses typically include tuition, fees, books, supplies, and equipment required for enrollment in eligible educational institutions. These expenses can vary depending on the educational institution and program. Importantly, this can encompass both undergraduate and graduate programs. Room and board expenses may also qualify if the student is enrolled at least half-time. It's essential to familiarize yourself with the specific guidelines to ensure you maximize the benefits of your 529 Plan. Funds are also available for K-12 education up to $10K per year. This versatility ensures that your savings can be utilized for various educational needs, providing peace of mind and financial stability. The opportunity to use 529 Plans for K-12 tuition expenses became available in 2018, and each state has additional requirements to look in to. Income Tax Breaks Besides the federal tax benefits, many states offer income tax breaks for contributions to a 529 Plan. Depending on your state, you may be eligible for deductions or credits for your assistance. These state tax advantages further enhance the tax benefits of a 529 Plan. Additionally, the tax-free growth and tax-free withdrawals for qualified education expenses at the federal level make this investment vehicle highly attractive from an income tax perspective.
25 May, 2023
Educate Yourself on a New Scam Affecting Schwab Users (and General Cybersecurity Tips) With the ever-expanding integration of technology into our daily lives comes great responsibility. Unfortunately, many people and organizations take advantage of the access that technology can give to individuals and use it to run scams. And as technology advances, so do scammers. Scammers can target your personal information, money, and other private details and assets you want to keep safe. Here at Clayton Financial Group, we value our client's safety and security above all else – let's discuss ways you can keep yourself protected from scams, including a new scam campaign that specifically targets Schwab clients. Scam Campaigns Scam campaigns are sophisticated, targeted efforts to steal information, money, or data from individuals over various mediums. While some may be more familiar with scams from overseas, plenty of scam campaigns originate in the United States and directly target Americans. Recent scams have become complex, using multiple avenues to execute the fraud: phone calls, text messages, emails, and even paper letters. A new scam campaign currently targets Schwab clients and uses letters, phone calls, and references to LinkedIn profiles. How They Work Here is how this current scam against Scwab customers works – while each scam is unique in execution, some of these steps are similar to other scams. Scammers target clients by sending a pop-up message that appears to be from Microsoft or Apple, alerting them that their computers have been compromised. The pop-up includes instructions to call a provided "tech support" number, which connects them to a fraudster. Upon contacting the fraudsters, the clients receive a call from someone posing as a Schwab "security officer," claiming that their Schwab account is compromised. The imposter instructs the victim to transfer their money into an account under "federal custody" to "protect their funds." They assure the client that they will return the money within three business days once they encrypt their account for safety. Trusting the instructions, the client follows through, only to find that their money vanishes. To make the scheme more believable, the scammers send personalized paper letters to the clients, supposedly from the Federal Reserve. These letters reference names and titles of actual Schwab personnel, tech company employees, and FDIC analysts, who are seemingly the individuals contacting them by phone. The letter encourages clients to verify the identity of each person through their LinkedIn profiles, adding an extra layer of credibility to the scam. How to Protect Yourself The best way to protect yourself against fraud is to stay informed and think critically. In the Schwab scam (and many others), the thieves rely on the fact that you will act immediately on their instructions. They create a false sense of urgency – but in general, just about any honest business or government organization will give you time to make a payment or a decision, not pressure you to act immediately. You should also always verify the phone numbers with the name of the person/organization you are speaking with because scammers can change their caller ID name. Regarding the Schwab scam, never grant anyone remote access to your account, and do not click on any links from a pop-up. What to Do If You Get Involved If you are the victim of a scam campaign, you should take action as soon as you realize it. Unfortunately, if there is money involved, it will likely be long gone before you can notify someone. That said, it's still worthwhile to take action. If the scammer used your bank account, contact your bank to let them know and ask to reverse the transaction. If the scammer has remote access to any of your devices, update your security software, change your passwords, and report the scam. Remember: these fraudsters are intelligent and sophisticated. Do not feel ashamed or embarrassed if you get involved; focus on what you can do now. More Best Practices to Avoid Scams Every scam is different, so taking a multi-faceted approach to avoid scams is crucial. Never answer calls from phone numbers you don't recognize, and block numbers that continually call and leave junk voicemails. Additionally, you should register your phone number on the Federal Trade Commission's National Do Not Call Registry and ensure the antivirus protection software on your computer is up to date. Remember that scammers often ask you to pay via a wire transfer service or cryptocurrency – be wary of any requests like this. In the end, before you act on anything, tell a family member or someone you trust about the incident, as telling someone else what happened can help bring clarity. Work With Clayton Financial Group At Clayton Financial Group, we help our clients achieve their plans for life and take their growth and security seriously. We are an independent boutique advisory firm with national coverage and decades of industry experience. If you're looking for help with investment planning, tax planning, risk management, estate planning, and more, look no further: let's connect today.
Share by: